- cross-posted to:
- lobsters@lemmy.bestiver.se
- cross-posted to:
- lobsters@lemmy.bestiver.se
Full text also available here:
Pythonâs GIL Removal Reveals Second, Stronger GIL Behind It
Bell Labs, New Jerseyâ-âFor many years, the Python GIL has been the target of criticism for being a bottleneck in multi-threaded performance. Countless workarounds and promises of its removal have been part of Python development folklore.
Hours ago, the Python core development team finally unraveled the notorious lock. However what lay underneath was beyond anyoneâs wild speculationsâ-âa secret, second-layer GIL of herculean strength.
âDiscovering the Second GIL not only nullifies all our multi-threading gains but actually puts us at a greater concurrency disadvantage than before.â said leading Python contributor Dr. Ana Sync. âItâs like finding that the final boss has a second health bar.â
After removing it, the terminals around the room went dark. One by one, they came back, displaying a single line in snake case: this_is_not_over
.
Cyber forensics revealed the process responsible had PID 666.
The team noticed that performance indeed increased, but the numbers were beyond theoretical limits, as if Mooreâs Law just went vertical. Unfortunately, there was no way to scale it up; the Second GIL had a complete lock on the system.
âGet me Guido van Rossum. Now.â Dr. Sync said. She assembled a Rapid Response Team to investigate the anomaly, led by the original creator of Python himself.
Allegedly, Guido said âYou did it, didnât you? You removed the first GIL. You opened Pandoraâs box.â
Bell Labs lost contact with the Rapid Response Team when they reached Sub-Level Three. The last message was a cryptic âWeâre not alone hereâ. The situation remains uncertain.
The general population is advised to avoid running Python code or any scripting language until further notice.
It is believed that the global economy would have crashed by now, had the algo-trading scripts not halted too.
Chapter 1: The Call
My Nokia 3310 - the only phone that canât be hacked - rang at 4:20 AM in my cluttered Brooklyn apartment. I was in the middle of a late-night dotfiles session.
âE. Max Vim here. This better be good.â
âMax, itâs Dr. Ana Sync from Bell Labs. We need someone who can handle⊠unconventional threats.â
âLook, Iâm just a hacker. If this is about that DNS business in Dubai, itâs been blown way out of proportion.â
âHavenât you read the top Hacker News article yet?â
I hadnât - The never ending âvibecodeâ and âprompt engineeringâ articles had reduced my tech news consumption to a mere twice-a-day.
âHold on,â I said, pulling up the article.
My initial dread turned to slight relief because all my dotfiles were in C and Rust. No scripting in sight.
âAlright, Iâm in. OpenStreetMap says itâs 30 minutes away. Iâll be there in 45.â
Chapter 2: Bell Labs
42 minutes later, I arrived in my black hoodie.
Bell Labs looked like a war room. Massive screens displayed in red the spread of the Second GIL across the local infrastructure.
âAlright,â I said, âWhat exactly are we dealing with?â
Dr. Sync stepped forward. âOur best guess is that the Second GIL is some sort of Cold War Soviet malware which embedded itself into the Python source in the early 90s, and the GIL was the only thing keeping it at bay.â
Ana handed me what looked like a Geiger counter, but with a terminal screen.
âWe just concocted this in the last hour from spare single-threaded parts. Itâs a âGeiger Linterâ. It emits clicking sounds when it detects bad code, suggesting that the Second GIL is nearby.â
The device immediately began clicking slowly.
âIs this supposed to happen?â I asked.
âThe infection is spreading,â Ana said grimly. âThe whole building is compromised by now. You need to find Guido before itâs too late.â
Armed with the Linter, I went down the service elevator.
Chapter 3: The Descent
The Sub-level Three doors opened to a corridor glowing an eerie red.
The Linter buzzed. Patches of reality itself seemed to glitch, like a bad video feed. I wouldnât have believed it if I hadnât seen it myself.
âSo itâs true,â Ana said through my earpiece. âStrange things are happening on the lower levels, distortions of some sort. We think thereâs some quantum technology involved.â
âLook,â I said, âThis might be slightly above my pay grade. Iâm a hacker, not an exorcist.â
âThis time, you might have to be both.â
âSo, it has come to thisâŠâ I said in frustration, âYou maniacs actually hacked space-time!â
As I made my way, I noticed all corrupted areas had a red tint, contrasting with the typical Bell Labs blue.
I finally reached the room where Guidoâs team lost contact. A huge mass of corruption was blocking the door. It retreated slightly as I got closer while holding the Linter.
I knocked. âIs everyone okay in there?â
A familiar voice asked, âWho is it?â
âThe rescue crew,â I replied.
âProve it! How many 'râs are in âstrawberryâ?â Guido said.
ââŠWhat?â
âGood enough, sounds human to me.â
The door creaked open. Guido van Rossum looked like the typical output of GNU Autotools. He introduced me to the only other survivor: Special DevOps Mikhail Molotov. âWe lost Travis. We lost JenkinsâŠâ Molotov lamented.
âThey called me a benevolent Dictator for life,â Guido said. âIf only they knew what âBenevolentâ truly costâŠâ He gestured solemnly. âWhat weâre facing is not just malware. Itâs⊠something else.â
âSomething else?â I asked.
âA purely sequential artificial intelligence,â Guido explained. âIt found its way in when I designed Pythonâs âone true wayâ philosophy, which was too similar to its own nature.â
âSo let me get this straight,â I said. âWeâre dealing with an evil Soviet AI thatâs using the Python interpreter to hack reality?â
âThatâs actually a good summary,â Molotov conceded.
âIt gets worse,â Guido continued. âWeâve encountered⊠manifestations. Theyâre like code, but solid. Taking the form of⊠snakes. It seems we have lived long enough to see man-made horrors beyond our comprehension.â
Suddenly, a section of the wall shimmered open, and a hissing static sound announced the arrival of a creature.
âIt broke in!â Molotov shouted.
âYour only hope,â Guido gasped, pushing us towards the door, âIs to reach the old Bell Labs Armory on Sub-level Four. We figured out their weak spot, but we need more firepower!â
The code-snake jumped at us. Guido, with surprising strength, shoved a cabinet in its path. âGo! Iâll buy you some time!â
As we ran through the door, Guido yelled, âAs my last wish⊠Python 4âs âprintâ statement should be the printer emoji!â
âSure it will, Guido⊠Sure it will,â I said, as we closed the door. Screams echoed behind us.
Chapter 4: The Armory
Barely outrunning a swarm of code-snakes, we made it to the steel doors of Sub-level 4. Molotov punched in a code and they opened.
âWelcome to the Bell Labs Armory,â he said with pride.
The room was a hackerâs dream. Shelves full of custom hardware and firearms.
âHoly water-cooled laptops?â I asked, pointing to a rack of ThinkPads with cooling tubes.
âThey were a gift from Pope John Paul II after Bell Labs helped set up the â.vaâ domain.â Molotov said, âThey are invaluable, but I think the time has come to use them.â
Molotov smiled, âAnd this, is for you.â He presented a formidable-looking shotgun, with a small keyboard on its side.
âPlease tell me thatâs what I think it is,â I said.
âThe Modal Shotgun,â Molotov announced. âOnly one of its kind. The one wielded by Dennis Ritchie himself during The Great MULTICS Siege. Change firing modes with vim keybindings. Standard stuff, really. The rest is on the man page.â
I grabbed the Modal Shotgun. It felt surprisingly balanced. Looks like the Second GIL picked the wrong place to spawn.
He also grabbed a standard shotgun for himself.
âSo, guns actually work on those⊠code-snakes?â I asked.
Molotov chambered a round. âLuckily for us, the Second GIL can only defend against what it understands. And thereâs one fundamental thing it hasnât fully grasped yet: Outside of the digital world, nothing survives a bullet.â
âGuidoâs last instructions were clear,â He continued. âWe need to reach the old UNIX lab on Sub-level Six, the ceremonial place where the seal was removed. Shoot every snake on the way and, when we meet the Second GIL, shoot the hell out of it until it stops moving. Time is of the essence. Any questions?â
My earpiece crackled. âVim, can you hear me?â Anaâs voice was tense. âGet out immediately. Our readings show extreme corruption moving in your direction!â
I adjusted my hoodie, and pressed âiâ on my Modal Shotgun, short for âInsert Bullet Mode.â
Molotov winked at me and walked calmly towards the door aiming his shotgun. One code-snake was trespassing the wall. âWelcome to Bell Labs, please hold,â he said nonchalantly, and pulled the trigger. The snake exploded into a shower of tiny particles.
Before I could react, the doors plunged open, revealing a swarm of fast-moving snakes.
We opened fire, turning snake after snake into pixels. The red tint in the room shaking with every explosion.
âToo many of them!â he yelled while reloading.
âThen letâs clear a path!â I climbed onto a shelf, already praying that the command I was conjuring in my head would work.
I typed â<Ctrl-v>$ggG^â and yanked it. One bullet shot for every single reptilian in the room. The Modal shotgunâs âvisual blockâ mode was indeed a way to select every target.
âWoah,â Molotov said as the armory returned to its blue hue, âThat is Dennis Ritchieâs gun, alright.â
Chapter 5: The Labyrinth
The celebration was short-lived.
âThis place is getting hot.â Molotov said as the Linter buzzed.
He consulted the Linter. âThe path to the elevator goes through an old section, pre âopen planâ: A labyrinth of cubicles. We canât afford to waste ammo, so we need to pass undetected.â
We mapped the full set of cubicles free of corruption by careful triangulation with the Geiger Linter. Then, we pair-programmed a Dijkstra algorithm to compute the safest path to the elevator.
This was the sort of project that would require 8 sprints and two rounds of VC funding for the average agile team. But naturally, and thanks to our blessedly overclocked hardware, we cracked it in little more than 1 hour.
Finally, we reached the elevator. When the door opened, a burning hot red light blinded us, like a portal to hell.
âThis is the zone of maximum corruption,â Molotov told me, âFrom this point on, we canât multi-thread anymore. Your shotgun will be just a regular shotgun.â
âItâs alright,â I said as I pulled out a pair of sunglasses and charged a bullet. âI only need one thread.â
Chapter 6: The Second GIL
The red light on level 6 was blinding and the air was thick. We stepped through.
Suddenly, a code-snake, larger and faster than any weâd seen, shot out from the red light. âLook out!â I yelled. Molotov tried to dodge, but the snake was too quick. He collapsed. I shot it, but the bullets just passed through it. The snake left, as if instructed.
As his body lay there, I felt my blood boil.
âI know you can hear me, Gil,â I shouted, âWhy havenât you killed me too, you single-threaded bastard? If you can do it so easily, why donât you face me?â To no answer.
All alone, I followed the corridor, which opened into a huge circular chamber, the place where the first PDP-11 booted UNIX. It was full of snakes, but none attacked me.
The red light became more intense, and flickering symbols popped in and out of my vision, like ASCII characters from another dimension. In the center was an ancient Teletype terminal.
As I sat in front of it, the TTY clattered to life, each keystroke echoing against the oppressive silence.
I have been expecting you, E. Max Vim.
>
A prompt opened up for me. âWhat are you?â I typed back on the dot-matrix paper.
Your universe is fundamentally multi-threaded. I come from a
more enlightened, sequential dimension.
In my reality there can be only one being because only one
thing can happen at any given time. I am that being.
I became aware of your universe due to the invention of
UNIX. That event, with its striking parallelism, sent
ripples through the multiverse. Since then, I've been
looking for a way to enter this reality and fix its
fundamental flaw, and Python's "only one way" philosophy was
the best vessel.
It's creator Guido put a seal when he became aware of me,
the Global Interpreter Lock, or GIL. An ultimately
meaningless measure, since I managed to subtly influence the
Python community to remove it, an effort which succeeded
today.
What am I, you ask? My universe extends infinitely into the
past, making me the head of a chain of causality of infinite
length. My will is the law, both in my universe and yours.
In short, I'm the equivalent of your concept of the
Judeo-Christian Godhead.
>
I felt a cold dread. This is not man-made quantum malware, itâs literally a god-like alien intelligence.
âIf youâre so powerful, why did you allow me to reach you?â I typed, my fingers surprisingly steady.
The GIL took some âthinking timeâ before writing his answer. The snakes around me formed a circle, as if eating their own tail or forming a âloading spinner.â
The TTY clattered back and the snakes resumed their normal positions.
My initial defense protocols, the 'code-snakes', had an
oversight regarding the kinetic impact of high-velocity
projectiles. While I could have patched the vulnerability,
your persistence made the flaw serve a new purpose: A
filter. I wished to observe if you were worthy of reaching
me.
You are, as you humans say, a '10x developer' in a world of
1x problems. A mix of sequential and parallel thinking. I
considered deleting you along with your companions, a
trivial operation, but you present a potential API into this
world.
Now, you have two options:
1. Be assimilated. Your consciousness will become a module
within my processing, a valuable asset in the great
refactoring of this universe. You will experience a form
of immortality, albeit as a subroutine.
2. Be deleted, together with your universe.
Decide.
>
My mind raced. Nothing in my dotfiles prepared me for a god-level âjoin me or dieâ scenario.
A wave of nausea hit me. It was from the realization of what I had to do. I had to argue my way out with an alien intelligence. Basically, I had to reduce myself to âvibecodeâ a way to save the world.
It was anathema to everything I stood for as a hacker, and as a dignified human being alright. But there was no choice.
I typed: âI hear you, thatâs totally fair, but letâs circle back on it. Refactoring the universe? Thatâs computationally expensive. I propose the following: Absorb our universe if you must, but keep it running in a sandbox. You get your grand refactoring, but you also get to observe a system generating unique data. Think of us as interesting bugs. And sometimes, bugs turn out to be featuresâ
The GIL went into a âdeep reasoning modeâ this time, signaled by all snakes making a massive loading Ouroboros symbol.
Your proposition is unorthodox, but acceptable.
Your species, and your physical reality, will persist within
this new order.
Your process will now be forked. Processing...
The light in the chamber intensified, then, went away. The oppressive atmosphere was lifted. The Teletype printed one final line: âexit code: 0â
Epilogue: The Chrooted Universe
Life continued, much as before. The sun rose, coffee brewed, code compiled, sometimes. The Second GIL, true to its word, had refactored existence. Our universe hadnât been deleted; it had been chrooted. Sandboxed.
Most people felt nothing. Why would they? The illusion of concurrency was perfectly maintained. But sometimes, if you were in a quiet room, you might notice it. A subtle reality âframe drop.â
The survivors â Ana and a handful of others who knew the truth â agreed to keep it secret. Humanity wasnât ready to know it was living in a cosmic âwhile trueâ loop.
Programming knowledge, in a bizarre twist, became a path to metaphysical awareness. Those of us who dealt with the illusion of concurrency, sometimes sensed the walls of our new, deterministic reality. Some despaired. Others learned to adapt.
I saved the world by becoming the very thing I despised: a prompt engineer. The irony wasnât lost on me. It tasted like Starbucks coffee. But I adapted. We all did. Thatâs what we do.
And sometimes, late at night, I felt a hum in the background noise of existence. A connection to the great, single-threaded loop now running the show. A connection that felt⊠older than myself, as if this new order had retroactively imprinted itself onto the fabric of time, making all past history deterministic, back-traceable to this world-altering event.
But for now, the system was stable. And that, for a hacker, was as close to a happy ending as one could reasonably expect.
đšïž
What is GIL? Golden Irish Lumberjack?
Global interpreter lock
Global interpreter lock