- cross-posted to:
- fuck_ai@lemmy.world
- cross-posted to:
- fuck_ai@lemmy.world
I received an e-mail alert from Steam that I received the community award 💯 for one of my posts. I follow the link included, but it just takes me to the community for Big Walk. I look through my comment history, and I find it. It’s a comment I had made critical of their failure to disclose their AI usage.
I haven’t even looked at the discourse about this issue, but from what I heard, it’s gotta be pretty heated. Your comment might’ve just been caught up in a swarm of lots of worse stuff people have been saying. And, regardless of who’s right, it’s gonna end up in a shouting match. Deleting those discussions is probably only healthy for everyone involved…
Also, like another said in the thread, AI coding assistance is not part of AI disclosure requirements on Steam, so they’re not lying? Now, I do believe it should be part of said requirements, though unlike other generative AI, unless someone tells on themselves, it’s gonna be a lot more difficult to prove they’re lying about that.
I do appreciate that they’ve talked about their AI use in this project. If it’s true what they’re saying, and they used it a single time to overcome a problem neither they nor that Unity engineer were experienced enough to solve, during a very stressful part of development trying to get the game done before launch, a game that probably had thousands of hours worth of human work involved … I’d be okay letting that one slide? I’d rather people be honest than us being left in the dark and uninformed. So… let’s cool down on the backlash maybe?
What I’m really interested in is what the AI policy they’re going to implement is going to look like.
If they do swear off AI completely, that’s a win for us, right?I thought they had to resort to that after exhausting all options directly with Unity to try and fix an engine bug affecting the game?
Seriously I can’t stand people like you. They found a bug, couldn’t fix it, asked the engineer working at Unity, he couldn’t come up with a fix, then they tried the LLM approach, which took some back and forth, and eventually the fix was ~10 lines of code.
I get that people dislike AI usage but you can’t be this blindly anti-ai. And you can’t put all “AIs” into one bag and call them the same.
This isn’t deceptive behavior, and if you think it is, and please keep in mind that I do mean this kindly and mean no disrespect, you might need professional help.I can stand people like them
Fuck ai
ok you know what, lets agree. All AI is bad unconditionally. And your game requires a AI disclosure if it was made with AI or any tools you use included AI. So if you use Unreal Engine, Unity, Godot, Visual Studio (Code), etc. then your game is officially AI slop and you need to put that AI disclosure on your store page. Sounds good to me.
Glad we came to a common understanding
Or if Linux was anywhere in the chain.
Using it for artistic purposes is shitty.
Using it to code isn’t that. There’s only so many ways to even code things in a given programming language, because it’s just math and logic. Using an AI to automate the tedious bullshit parts of coding is perfectly acceptable to me. Just don’t use it to make the visuals, audio, or story; the things that only mean something when expressed by humans.
So their engineer doesn’t know how to engineer?
The engineers who wrote the engine couldn’t even engineer the problem away. So the engineers of the company are not at fault in my eyes.
Skill issue
It is unreasonable to expect a human to know everything, and this doubly counts in the world of software engineering where weird edge cases exist.
Who said I expect that?
Programmers successfully made games without AI for many years in the past. None of them knew everything.
Expecting software to know anything is unreasonable.
no one wants anyone to know they used AI because they know everyone hates AI
Because it doesn’t even violate the steam disclosure rules. And debugging is one of the use cases where it makes the most sense to be using it.
How does it not violate Steam’s disclosure rules? This literally fits in the Pre-Generated category of rules, having used generated code. Even if it was only 10 lines.
Key Rules & Requirements
• Player-Consumed Content (Must Disclose): Developers must report generative AI if it is used to create assets consumed by players (such as art, music, dialogues, voice acting, text, and localization) that ship with the game or appear in marketing materials.
• Backend & Efficiency Tools (Exempt): AI tools used strictly behind the scenes—such as coding assistants (e.g., GitHub Copilot), debugging helpers, workflow automation, internal office work, or discarded concept art not shipped in final game files—do not require disclosure.
Pre-Generated: Any kind of content (art/code/sound/etc) created with the help of AI tools during development.
So they are contradicting themselves.
That specific quote—“Any kind of content (art/code/sound/etc) created with the help of AI tools during development”—comes from Valve’s original January 2024 policy launch, which has since been superseded.
You could literally just have googled this shit.
So what? The game is great




