• Balder@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    edit-2
    1 day ago

    it’s his platform, he can do whatever he wants on it, he paid a lot of money for it. […] I really don’t get why this would upset anyone

    lol

    1. Champions “free speech” to justify buying Twitter in a legitimate way.
    2. Wins over idealists who think they’re fighting for openness, calling it a “public square”, “Greek Agora” etc.
    3. Bans critics and content he just doesn’t align with.
    4. Gets called out.
    5. “Whoa whoa, I meant my free speech. The rest of you? Peasants.”
    6. People leave the platform: “I don’t get why this upsets anyone, it’s his platform”.

    This reminds me of the behavior most common in subreddits such as /r/Bitcoin, we can even put it side by side:

    • Step 1: Preach a grand ideal — “X is the free speech Agora!” / “Bitcoin is your path to financial freedom!”
    • Step 2: Rally support by moralizing it — “If you’re against this, you’re against liberty!” / “Only fools ignore Bitcoin!”
    • Step 3: When the consequences hit — censorship or market crashes — suddenly the ideal becomes personal: “It’s his platform, he can do whatever he wants.” / “You fool! You shouldn’t have invested more than you can afford to lose.”
    • Jeena@piefed.jeena.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      3
      ·
      1 day ago

      You’re misunderstanding what I wrote, because:

      People leave the platform: “I don’t get why this upsets anyone, it’s his platform”.

      Is exactly the opposite of what I was trying to say with:

      he is not forcing you to use his platform

      you can just leave, there are so many alternatives available, if you don’t then you are part of the problem, giving him power and putting more money into his pockets. In fact you should have seen the writing on the wall many years ago and latest when he bought it.

      Being upset about this now after he did so many worse things is just silly.

      • Balder@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        6 hours ago

        you can just leave, there are so many alternatives available […] In fact you should have seen the writing on the wall many years ago and latest when he bought it.

        Yeah I know what you’re saying, and I agree — many people left Twitter back then indeed. But many people will still get bothered with the hypocrisy of this sort of behavior persisting in their society. Anything is justified at the moment it is convenient, then when the hypocrisy is pointed out, suddenly the problem is the person who fell for it. It feels a bit like an US cultural thing, where the damage of something to society isn’t really discussed, after all, we all have “free will”, so the fault is on the person who didn’t know better. But you’re gonna be affected by these things one way or another regardless of whether you try to ignore them.

        There are enough fools in the world who will keep giving billionaires more and more power, no matter what they do, because America’s current indoctrination glorifies the ultra-rich (the dominant class in the U.S.) in the same way authoritarian countries indoctrinate their citizens to worship a strong leader who promises to take care of everything for them.