Welcome to another general discussion thread! Feel free to use this thread to talk about things you have watched recently, questions you have, or recommendations you want to give!
As always, remember to be mindful of spoilers. If you want to know more about how to handle spoilers in this community, check the guide here (also linked in the sidebar).
This Season
Meta thoughts:
I like how Cinderella Gray’s rankings on various anime charts mirror Oguri’s rise in the anime. Truly an underdog story.
I also like the implication of this rise:
- the episodes just keeps getting better and better
- its low popularity at the start is only due to a lack of hype - the moment people gave it a chance (like I did), they immediately recognise how good it is
Also, these anime-ranking sites’ treatment of To Be Hero X
spoiler for Cinderella Gray
reminds me of the events in the Cinderella Gray. Can an anime-of-the-week truly deserve its title if a worthy opponent was barred from competing because of technicalities?
Anime Trending
Girl of the week
Anime of the week
Anime Corner
r/anime
week 2 (episode 1) rank: 21
week 3 rank: 20
week 4 rank: 17
week 5 rank: 19
week 6 rank: 16
week 7 rank: 12
week 8 rank: 12
week 9 rank: 11
Apologies, but you will have to wait a day or two for my normal comments in these threads due to traveling on my part. I just don’t have the literal or figurative bandwidth to do much atm.
I finished ARIA the natural. It’s very good again. Especially the OST and Athena’s songs. I don’t think I’ve seen so many golden hour shots in an anime ever. I’m a great enjoyer of golden hour, tender music and a some sappy lines.
Binged go go loser ranger first season. Will watch second season even though first season middle episodes were a little weak. Hope second season is more constant.
Past Seasons
I completed a bunch of top-tier anime over the past week.
Toradora
After holding it off for so long, I rewatched Toradora yet again so that I can give it a proper rating on AniList (instead of doing so based on vague memories of the show).
Even after so long, it is still peak drama. The animation quality from pre-2010s held up, as did its soundtrack and artstyle. But what made it stood the test of time is its character writing and story-telling.
I like how every character can simultaneously be immature and mature. I love how the drama put their relationships through the wringer.
There’s no doubt that it is getting a score of 10 / 10 from me. Each episode got me hooked and wanting for more.
The harder test is whether it can enter my top favourites (i.e. top 10). For an anime to make it to my top favourites one vague criterion I have is rewatchability: it must leave a deep enough impression for me to want to rewatch it multiple times. Ultimately, I dropped Belle in favour of Toradora.
Link Click season 1
I heard that Link Click shares the same director as To Be Hero X. Apparently, he is a master of plot twists.
So I know I just had to check Link Click out. And boy, it certainly did not disappoint. I love the non-linear story-telling, as well as good it is at building suspense. The soundtrack Sign helped a lot.
Most importantly,
mild meta spoiler for Link Click
I enjoy how the show waits for you to drop your guard before revealing the twist.
Also,
spoiler for Link Click S1 (and S2 maybe?)
I bet Xiao Shi would end up changing the past to save his friends. My bigger bet is that he ended up finding his parents and either
- changed the past to save them
- caused his parents disappearance in the first place
This is peak suspense, well-deserving of a 10 / 10. I will be picking season 2 up real soon.
Umamusume: Pretty Derby
With how good Cinderella Gray turned out, I thought I should give the series another chance after dropping season 1 - only one episode in - a while back. Shout-out to @selayar@ani.social for the movie recommendations.
Also, I inadvertently found out that the series is based on real-life race horses and ended up spoiling myself (probably like many others).
Road to the Top
Personally, I find that Road to the Top is quite a standard sports anime. It was a well-made movie. It knows how to get you to empathise with the protagonist’s struggles.
Normally, there would be more that I would comment on, but it got completely overshadowed by the next one I watched. I actually can’t remember some details of the show (e.g. I forgot Admire Vega’s name and had to check the AniList characters page).
It’s still really good though, so for now, I’m giving it a 9 / 10.
Season 2
This is it. Straight-up the best show I have watched all week. I don’t think I will be able to find a 1-season(12/13 episodes)-long, standalone sports anime that can rival Umamusume: Pretty Derby - season 2.
I noticed that its rating is higher compared to season 1 and 3, and heard that each season can be watched as a standalone show, so I decided to give it a shot. Its rating was lower than that of Beginning of a New Era though, so I saved what is potentially the best for the last.
Cinderella Gray may have been the lure to get me hooked, but Season 2 is the powerhouse that truly reeled me into the series proper.
When it comes to sports anime, I would expect an underdog story - one of a protagonist who’s constantly underestimated (and often ridiculed) by others, but eventually achieve their dream of being at the top through sheer will and effort.
Pretty Derby did not follow this formula. Instead, it gave us Tokai Teio, this cheery horse-girl who’s in her prime and nigh-unstoppable (neigh-unstoppable? XD)
Pretty Derby S2 spoiler
at the start. Then crush her dreams not once, not twice but thrice. Fate is even so cruel as to go after her best friend Mejiro McQueen too.
She no longer has any title to defend. Her fans may still like her, but they no believe that she can win. She was essentially seen as washed-up.
But she never gave up.
Her story reminded me of
meta spoiler 1
Ema from Medalist, though unlike Tokai Teio, Ema didn’t have any achievement to her name.
I thought I couldn’t draw parallels to any other characters till I realised there’s no need to limit myself to sports anime (or even anime).
meta spoiler 2
Suletta from the Witch from Mercury started the series as an underdog, then quickly proved herself as the show progresses. By the start of the second season, nobody can dispute that she is the best pilot in the academy.
Then she started taking Ls after Ls, all the way till the very end of the show, where she pulled off a miracle through pure willpower, determination, grit.
Notice that the previous paragraph applies to Tokai Teio too.
A meta similarity is that both are really just high quality commercials:
meta spoiler 3
Umamusume’s goal is to draw in more players for their gacha game, whereas Gundam’s is to sell more Gunpla.
And you know what? It’s working - on me, and on the numerous fans.
Also, the show-creators definitely knew what they were doing by portraying Teio as a happy-go-lucky, extra cheery girl. It is just like
meta spoiler 4
Inside Out. When the most joyful character breaks down, it makes for the most heart-breaking moment.
In short, Pretty Derby S2 is the most moving show I have seen in the last few weeks. Also, I have lost count of the number of times that I have rewatched that legendary last race.
You know the score it’s getting: 10 / 10, easily
Beginning of a New Era
After the peak that is Pretty Derby S2, I had superbly high expectations for Beginning of a New Era.
I can immediately see why it received such a high rating: its animation is on-par with the best animated shows of all time.
Unfortunately, I find that Tokai Teio’s story set the bar too high for Jungle Pocket’s to clear.
I can definitely see the similarity:
umamusume spoiler
both are about rehabilitation. Though in Jungle Pocket’s case, it is mental instead of physical.
However, I prefer Teio’s story.
It doesn’t mean its not good. I just don’t find it as good as Pretty Derby S2. 9 / 10
Now that I’ve went deep into the Umamusume rabbit hole, season 3 is next on my list. I may even try season 1 again for completion’s sake.
As someone who also only get into Uma Musume franchise thanks to Cinderella Gray, I’m happy seeing another comrade also enjoying Uma Musume through the same route. Now, I have high expectation for S2, because BoaNE was phenomenal.
