Welcome again to everybody. Make yourselves at home. In the time-honoured tradition of our group, here is the weekly discussion thread.
☭ Matrix homeserver and space
☭ Theory discussion group on /c/theory@lemmygrad.ml
☭ Find theory on ProleWiki, marxists.org, Anna’s Archive


Do you allow yourself to feel defeated from time to time? Like, “damn, being a communist is hard” or “this world sucks.”
I have these moments, but I don’t know if they are healthy or not.
(Thanks for the answers. I really appreciate them)
To each their own but i think some struggle is definitely healthy, with some caveats of course, i.e. no one should work 3 turns to survive.
Almost every communist leader could’ve lived an easy life, as most were born in privilege and highly educated, yet they chose the hard route to make the world a better place.
I think it’s pretty normal to not be in high spirits about it all the time. Where it would probably count as unhealthy is if it was an actual active belief like “there’s no way communism can win because xyz” kind of thing, or if it was general dooming like “we’re doomed because the species sucks” or something.
Personally, though I have low moments for sure, I don’t tend to feel that communism itself is in trouble because I’m confident that due to the way contradictions work, support for it will keep popping up and due to dialectical and historical materialism being a science, people would rediscover it even if it was majorly repressed. But also, China is right there and is doing quite well. The imperial core itself, I don’t know, it’s hard to be optimistic about it sometimes. But I think things are going to reach a point where that doesn’t matter very much for the rest of the world and they will be able look on the (one day former) empire regions with pity rather than fear.
Just like every revolution goes through periods of advancement and periods of retreat, so too do revolutionaries go though easy and difficult periods. It is important not to fear or deny that these periods are happening but to maintain our revolutionary discipline during them. To understand that defeat and temporary retreat are a fact of life but that this does not imply that we give up our goal or our hope.
Everytime I read something from Lenin, his position as being as important as Marx and Engels is validated.
Like, he gets people (like me lol) going even after being dead for 100 years. He just has so many banger quotes.
thanks for this quote!
Highly recommend reading this entire speech at some point if you have the time. Despite dealing with pragmatic, practical issues of the time, it is imo still very much applicable to today, especially in regards to China and the ultra-left criticism of China’s path:
And this part was especially amusing to me:
He’s arguably the best of the “Five Heads” (I hate that we over-focus on just those five but whatever).
Resistance is a process of going from defeat to defeat until victory.
Learn to enjoy the struggle.
❤️
I don’t trauma-dump.
I tell war stories.
It depends. It’s hard to achieve change, but it’s not that hard to work towards it (depending on situation). What I’ve “sacrificed” is spending some time reading and writing and trying to organize and talk to people. So the “sacrifice” is spending some of my time on learning, intellectual activity, being social, and political activity - all imporant parts of living a good human life IMO. I don’t really think I get to feel that it is so hard when I know that there are many people who have worked much harder and made actual sacrifices.