People elect their municipal and county Peoples Congress. Those congresses choose the various department heads and mayor etc. as well as their representative at the next level of government with each level of government selecting their representative in the next level up. They are not just chosen because of popularity but because of their track record of effectiveness and their commitment to the project of Socialism with Chinese Characteristics.
Then on another track the people elect the Peoples Deputies who are a legal oversight body that asses the effectiveness and capability of the members of the Peoples congress. They ask the hard questions to hold the ministers to account for their actions and policies. They can’t just be waved away as “politicking” because the Deputies aren’t aiming for the congress member’s job like in the Westminster system. Their questions demand answers and their findings, good or bad are, not forgotten. They follow the same system of electing the representatives for the next level.
Thirdly you have the Consultation process at every level of government. There are Residents Councils and other councils or “tea rooms” that hold meetings between residents, officials, and deputies to discuss issues effecting the people. These councils are set up so the Peoples congress can get accurate information from people at the grassroots level at what is needed and what is working to address the needs and also to carry out the policies set by the peoples congress.
Thank you for this explanation. If you don’t mind, can you please expand on the ‘people’s deputies’ part?
They are the Quality Assurance branch of the government. They do inquiries, and audits, they can officially question peoples congress officials and departments as well as talking to the public about suggestions, criticisms and opinions.
You know how opposition parties are meant to keep the governing party “honest” by talking shit and demanding answers during question time or during senate hearings? kinda like that but the deputies aren’t trying to get the People’s congress members job. So they aren’t trying to catch them out on any little thing for sound bites they just want to make sure the job is getting done.
So people vote for the team who will make up their towns government but then they also vote for the team that will audit their towns government and keep them focused on delivering what the town needs.
Thank you again. Shit… this system might actually be drastically more democratic and people-centric than the popular vote democracy we have in the west.
might
It is
But my Le Epic leftwing commentators in the west told me China doesn’t have democracy and is a one-man dictatorship.
yeah. Its all bottom up with feedback loops and auditing built right in parallel but not in an adversarial way. The “checks and balances” don’t try to pull eachother down or hold each other back but instead keep things moving forward and adjusting for obstacles.
It makes it so obvious that the western representative democracies were always designed to make workers think they have a say while protecting the wealthy from them.
Check out Socialism in Power by Roland Boer
Big fan
Same, it’s a great read
Progressive International - Building Whole Process People’s Democracy in China
Are you looking for something like this?
I think we have fascism as oligarchy’s with a democratic mask/facade. Liberal democracy doesn’t exist imho, so I wouldn’t know how to compare a theoretical ideology with the Chinese system. Maybe the continuous vetting process of candidates are the biggest surprise relative to our populistic facade circus?
Anyway, Harvey has an easy informative video introduction on the chinese system. He’s young but surprisingly knowledgeable. https://youtu.be/By-X25PGf5k
Real liberal democracy has never been tried. /s
Liberal democracy does exist, but it serves the ruling bourgeois class, not the proletariat.
The Harvey video you shared is quite good. It doesn’t quite answer OPs question, but it provides some important insights into the Chinese system.
I found a YouTube link in your comment. Here are links to the same video on alternative frontends that protect your privacy:







