This is our species in a nutshell.
That plus probably being exposed to covid. Apparently it has really bad effects on the brain and ability to learn.
Don’t forget that we also don’t give kids enough breaks to let their brains actually process what they just learned and be able to put it all away. Your brain isn’t meant to just absorb 8 hours of information with just a lunch break and a few minutes of passing time. That isn’t enough, you need several long breaks so your brain can actually absorb what you are learning. Otherwise it just all gets lost since it effectively becomes white noise.
Oh also don’t forget that schools were designed to create obedient factory workers who don’t question orders. That surely has no impact on students ability to actually do work. You don’t need creative thinking at all, just shove everything into as few boxes as possible.
Summer vacations as they exist in the US are counter productive, pointless and a hold over from pre-industrial schooling when rich families would pull their kids out of school during the hot summers to go somewhere cooler leaving the school with less funding and without their stat pupils so the trend rapidly developed of just going to extended recess till the weather cooled and rich kids returned.
The argument that it was for farmers is patently false. Farmers plant in the spring and harvest in the fall, both times schools are in session. And livestock farmers have year round commitments so the idea of pulling students only for the summer is equally silly. It all comes down to rich kids.
A sensible school calendar would be year round, with those 6-8 weeks of summer break broken up and spliced elsewhere into the calendar, reducing the amount of material students would forget, basically the entire first quarter coming back for most schools is just going over everything learned the previous spring to catch up. It’s not one for one but by the time kids get through 8th grade almost 2 years of their schooling has been spent relearning something they already learned.
We could do so much better for kids if we abandoned the ridiculous calender most schools use and alter the actual hours kids are in school to better reflect on what they learned and absorb it rather than just memorizing enough for the next test and moving on.
I understand your point and it’s a good argument. But I gotta tell ya… I REALLY miss having a few months of where I can play and just live my life and do what I love. I learned some important life lessons during that break that you just wouldn’t get being in school all year round.
I think we should leave the kids alone for a couple months per year and let them live. Life isn’t just about work.
Counterpoint, wouldn’t it be better to have 3 weeks for Christmas, 2 weeks for spring break/easter, 2 weeks in the summer and then an extra week or two break in the fall? Depending how you organize it kids could have up to 2 weeks off after every quarter/major exams.
Or, going the other direction, you could condense it down to every other or even every Friday off, meaning 3 days weekends and 4 day work weeks for youth.
I get the sentiment, that having 2 months or more off as a kid was great and I certainly enjoyed it at the time, but looking back it was such a bad system and I certainly would have adapted better to school if I had more breaks from it throughout the year rather than one long absence in the summer. It’s not that summer vacation needs go away entirely, it just needs to be revamped to a more manageable break and that excess time off spread out throughout the year, particularly around times where students experience the most stress so they can decompress.
I’m sure we can find a middle ground, yes.
Obviously more testing is required! I used to walk to school up hill both ways and got the switch if I complained! Kids just don’t want to learn anymore! /s
Also I remember how much it sucked in a building w/out AC, so with these new spring/fall heat waves I’d be dead. Lucky in the US we have a party undoing education for the mid-class/poor so that only the rich that do fuck all will get an education. Part of their “keep the work force dumb and working” agenda.
