sometimes a dragon

he/they, queer, furry, ζ, vegan

  • 0 Posts
  • 98 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: September 7th, 2024

help-circle







  • Ugh, I’m so fucking tired of this shit.

    I can imagine that an LLM can find bugs. Bugs often follow common patterns, and if anything, an LLM is a pattern matcher, so if you let it run on the whole world of open source code out there, I’m sure it’ll find some stuff, and some of it might be legit issues.

    But static code analysis tools have been finding bugs for decades, too. And now that an AI slop machine does it, it’s supposed to bring about dystopian sci-fi alien wars?

    Why are people hyped about that?

    (Also this poster makes wrong claims about every exploit being worth millions and such, but the rest of it is so much more ridiculous, it drowns out the wrongness of those claims.)





  • Very impressed with this comment from the creator of the Zig programming language, regarding dealing with AI slop submissions, and generally about LLMs for coding.

    I should look into Zig again! Technically, I’ve always leaned more towards Rust, because I like its more uncompromising approach to safety, while Zig always seemed to me a bit more middle-of-the-road on that. But I’ve been disappointed about how wide-spread LLM usage has become in Rust circles, I fear that its culture might tip over in favor of slop. (But it’s not there yet and I hope it won’t happen!)

    Anyway, I’m ordering the ā€œIntroduction to Zigā€ book…


  • This could be regarded as a neat fun hack, if it wasn’t built by appropriating the entire world of open source software while also destroying the planet with obscene energy and resource consumption.

    And not only do they do all that… it’s also presented by those who wish this to be the future of all software. But for that, a ā€œneat fun hackā€ just isn’t enough.

    Can LLMs produce software that kinda works? Sure, that’s not new. Just like LLMs can generate books with correct grammar inside, and vaguely about a given theme. But is such a book worth reading? No. And is this compiler worth using? Also no.

    (And btw, this approach only works with an existing good compiler as ā€œoracleā€. So forget about doing that to create a new compiler for a new language. In addition, there’s certainly no other language with as many compilers as C, providing plenty of material for the training set.)