Every instance hates every other instance, but none more than .ML and .world hate each other
Beans.
Lemmy as a whole is extremely anti-AI, pro-socialism, and pro-LGBT, and the comment sections can be pure freaking insanity.
Because there are significantly fewer people here, there’s considerably more engagement on individual posts. That doesn’t mean the crazies don’t exist, though. They very much do, and there seem to be a disproportionately large number of them.
On Reddit, you can post dozens of comments and receive very little engagement. Here, you can post a single comment and get a massive amount of interaction. That’s the biggest difference I’ve noticed.
I find myself arguing about generally the same things, too. For example, people who are excessively anti-AI often don’t really understand what they’re talking about because they don’t use the technology. They don’t understand what it actually does, what it’s capable of, or what it’s intended to accomplish. As a result, there’s a lot of ignorance you can counter simply by explaining the technology.
Then there’s socialism. A lot of people seem to fundamentally misunderstand what it means. They advocate for socialism while conflating social programs and the economic system itself, as though the two are interchangeable. They’re not.
And, of course, there’s the overwhelming LGBT support. I’m absolutely on board with supporting LGBT rights. People are people. Their sexual orientation shouldn’t define how we view them, but I also don’t think it needs to become someone’s entire personality. Frankly, that’s extremely boring.
You’re going to encounter some viewpoints that you’ll rarely see on reddit. This may come as quite a shock to you. Many people are tempted to blame this on “bots”, which doesn’t stand up to reason. Imagine you want to influence public opinion through a bot campaign. How high would Lemmy rank on your priority list? Keep an open mind, and don’t assume that opinions that challenge your own are disingenuous.
Idk, I read the person that made lemmy was an extremist, and they can do loads of things to push their agenda besides “bots.”
Sure, I guess they probably could. But what for example? I see a lot of complaints about “bots”. I don’t know if people genuinely believe it, but I see it a lot.
This isn’t the Lemmy core code, but the Tesseract front end client blocking certain instances with a hard-coded list is a good example of the kinds of things that could be done by a developer.
And the XZ Utils hack shows how deeply the issue could be buried…that one was only found because someone wondered why SSH logins were taking a few more milliseconds.
I don’t see why someone wouldn’t run bots here - after they are set up, it’s minimal upkeep on them, isn’t it? If you wanted to sway opinions, why not run them here?
Because of the limited impact? Look at Facebook and Reddit: huge platforms with well-documented bot problems. Look what they are pushing. Liberalism and fascism. Leftist and anti imperialist views not only aren’t being pushed, they are actively suppressed. Who would run leftist bots on Lemmy, that wouldn’t bother running them on larger platforms? If Lemmy were just as much a target for bots as those other platforms, why is the flavor of conversation here so obviously different?
To push extremist content and make it seem valid and popular and spread its hostilities like a plague through the herd.
Extremism like say, support for the global hegemon and its status quo of genocide and war-profiteering? That is what you get everywhere else.
If you see an insane comment from lemmy.ml instance, dont feed the trolls.
You know how reddit is full of shills, morons, the socially oblivious, and a handful of cool people? Lemmy is like that except the instances nicely divide them for you more or less by category in advance!
Also, I find there is not much middle ground: you pick your minority group (queer, trans, vegan, Linux - [DE, FOSS, security, rice], neurodivergent, leftist / communist / tankie, furry, etc etc), you ramp your idealism to 11, then you comment like you’re 17 and nothing in the world is more important.
You know how Churchill said: “Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of Government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.”? Lemmy is that to it’s alternatives.
The people on Lemmy are smarter I think by whatever average you might take, but as time goes on I’m starting to think the userbase is, on the whole, more irritating than reddit. Just make sure you say “slop” slot and you’ll fit right in.
Bro calls out a bunch of people but leaves out turbolibs and cryptofash, and hangs it on a Churchill quote.
Etc. => et cetera => latin for “and others”
It wasn’t a cryptofash turbolib that showed up, it was, wouldn’t you know it, someone from the named groups, self sorted by instance and with that 17 year old swagger. That’s what I love about .ML: you don’t do anything but bitch on the internet, but at least we can rely on you to show up to prove a point!
It’s nice to be able to block an instance, but I still have to see the edgy and dumb shit the users who call it home comment.
I’d be happy to quote someone besides Churchill, but he happened to make the quote I wanted. Bro can downvote and move on.
It wasn’t a cryptofash turbolib that showed up
Of course it wasn’t, you’re already here, whining about the mean minorities.
We caught a second one increasingly proving my point.
Pick a minority group, take yourself too seriously, and rage post. Just sign off and go seize the means of production already.
I think the “.ml” is another oddity of Lemmy.
On reddit we were all from the same instance. But here we sign up to different servers. So our user names are tagged with a last name from that server. A family as it were. I personally almost never check where people are from but others habitually do. You are allowed to sign up to any server, pick your name.
Idk if I set it or it came that way, but Voyager just shows me the “full name” of everybody all the time.
Shit.s.all.cry.pto.fash
Can I ask some ELI5 questions, people might wonder (that I don’t think I could explain as well as others can)
- What are instances, really tho?
- Also I notice some instances have reputations (let’s not go there, but) what are some super mild instance suggestions for new people to choose, possibly?
- What are the apps you can use to access Lemmy, and what are the pros cons you’ve noticed for using them?
- How do you find stuff?
- Any super awesome sub suggestions / lists to follow?
Welcome aboard! Been here a few years.
- Think of Lemmy like a street, and every house is having a little party but they all share back yards. Each instance are the differant houses, they invite and cultivate vibes depending on shared culture. Some houses took down their fences so they can share a bigger back yard (federating), some have reputations for being THAT neighbor and so they put up curtains to block those people out (defederating). Really tho, instances are servers run by private individuals who upkeep and cultivate networks of content like we’re sharing here.
2.-3. I use voyager app on iOS and suggest sh.it just.works as an instance , very chill, federated with the big ones, most of the toxic ones are defederated. Lot of politics but you can filter it out. Voyager can be tweaked in a number of ways, I have mine set up to look like old Reddit style.
-
I struggle with finding a lot of things here. Unfortunately I think there is only so many people, so there’s only so much to find. lot of hollow communities that were set up without any people to fill them when I was joining Lemmy. Look for what’s active and ask around.
-
Niche communities are hard to find because people, but more general places are fairly well populated and lively - Onehundredandninetysix, shitpost, lots of comics like Farside and Calvin and Hobbes.
You can make notes on individual users and that will save you an unbelievable amount of time when deciding to participate in a conversation or not. The number of people that are repeat commenters and either trolls/unsocial/morons is more noticable on Lemmy because of the size. Instead of wondering “is this person a good and normal human with one bad take and therefore I should earnestly try to engage with them” you can see your note that says “hates gays” or “textbook idiot” and realize this is a pattern.
Maybe you can, but either that’s not implemented on all instances, or they hide that option somewhere in plain sight.
Oh, that’s interesting. I’m on Connect, I guess it’s a feature of that app? Whoops. Welllllll… Would highly recommend an app that lets you do that.
It’s much more a small community. You’ll start to see some of the same people everywhere. It’s almost small enough to remember names. People are more likely to kindly explain, rather than tear you down for not knowing. But there are a few dickheads, maybe they’re having a bad day and taking it out on in comments, maybe they have low compassion and empathy development and rigid thinking. You don’t owe anyone your time, if it’s not a positive experience and nobody is talking in good faith. Block and enjoy the slightly more peaceful environment. Downvotes don’t matter, nobody holds grudges, it doesn’t matter if you mess up, just keep swimming, we want you here in all your glory.
The algorithm here isn’t malicious and designed to hook you in, so you will go through a stage of withdrawal from the more malicious algorithms you have (hopefully) left entirely. Bear with it, it feels so much nicer to engage with something that doesn’t hook you in and rile up your anxiety. Once the withdrawal passes, and your brain acclimatises to the slower less stress inducing pace here, it feels like chatting with a small group of friends with an all inclusive sense of humour.
People here are smart! They’ll assess things and bring receipts along in their comments and it’s refreshing. Less knee jerk reacting from emotions.
Be unabashedly who you are, you don’t have to build a persona here, to be accepted, bring all your weird. The weirdest are the coolest here.
Edit: why does my autocorrect hate me so much!
You’ll start to see some of the same people everywhere
Then I scrolled through some more comments and read the names, and recognized one: yours. Haha
Man idk about that “people are smart” paragraph. Lemmy is not immune to groupthink and it seems extremely archetypal in perspectives for its pillar groups. You are right that “weird” is accepted, but I would say the point is more to be weird than smart: you can be queer, trans, a vegan, a furry, neurospicy, violet08, a tankie, a “carnivore”, etc. etc., but you have to be an idealist about it.
Come to Lemmy with non-idealist viewpoints and you’re setting yourself up for a hard time.
People are more extreme and absolutist here than on Reddit. Also, I’d recommend not reading your notifications, for your mental health.
Instances are very different and have a higher level of variance than Reddit’s subs.
Getting banned from ml is routine. Hexbear will hate you regardless of anything. Startrek.website is run by a complete nutter. Tankies are everywhere. Double check that community you see in All before you comment. Eat fruit.
I have never been banned from .ml, how exactly is that routine?
Dude even google summaries knows it’s a common affair. Its a large instance, it shows up in a lot of feeds and quite a few community mods are trigger happy
It has never happened to me.
And i’ve never seen snow. Does that make it an impossibility?
I didn’t say it was impossible, did I?
I was just saying that it’s surprising to me you would call it a routine thing for everyone, since it has never happened to me.
So you’re arguing the frequency and experience of other users, simply because it has never happened to you, personally?
No! I’m saying your statement surprised me, because of my individual experience. That’s all.
Are you trying to fight about something?
Relatedly, there is a feature in the settings to hide content from particular instances, sublemmies, and people. I found it helpful for hiding posts from instances that have banned me.
I came to the comments specifically because I knew some people would be trying to poison a newcomer with bullshit about the actual leftist instances here. Hexbear only hates you if you are a racist, nazi, troll, etc, or coming to wreck. Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
I was certainly suprised by the faceful of vitriol I observed when people did.
Also hexbear has been defederated from multiple instances for bad behaviour up to and including dogpiling, brigading and death threats to users in other instances, so please don’t pretend that it’s all people Being Mean to you
Do you have an example of the specific vitriol? People have been banned from hexbear for that sort of stuff, I’m not claiming everyone who has posted there is perfect and graceful and there are a wide range of mods with different levels of tolerance or views on punishment. The level of vitriol that promoters of imperialism deserve is a common point of contention. There have been many cases of anti-commies or others coming just to troll so some people misunderstand “good faith posters” as being wreckers.
The defederations you talk about are usually done by an admin that doesn’t like being called out for transphobia or racism and the users of those instances don’t even have a chance to see the truth of the situation.
including dogpiling, brigading and death threats
I mean we all know the death threats have literally never happened, it’s always .worlders claiming it happened before they defederated, despite them never being federated in the first place. The other two are just complaining that Hexbears have access to the front page and will engage with posts that come across it. It’s all just libs crying about getting called out for their racist, sexist, and transphobic views and policies.
Come ask questions about imperialism or “tankies” or anything at all in good faith, you might be surprised.
I’m gonna have to disagree. As someone who has wandered into Hexbear and .ml threads on multiple occasions without realizing it, asking questions did not yield positive interactions. Whenever this comes up and I talk about my experiences, I always get Hexbear or .ml users who try to downplay it, imply it’s just wounded ego, insist I must have been rude/hateful/belligerent, etc. Those communities very quickly turn hostile if you express anything other than already understanding and agreeing with them.
Do you have an example of one of the questions? I agree users that post there can be hostile, and some could use more patience before jumping to accusations of trolling or whatever, but honestly everytime I’ve seen someone say this sentiment it turns out they were being racist, using slurs, or didn’t understand how what they posted was racist or imperialist propaganda and doubled down with hostility when called out.
I had a hell of a time getting any sort of source on the claim that Ukraine is full of and/or run by Nazis, for example. I don’t remember the exact wording I used, but I generally tried to be polite and inquisitive, just looking for more information on the claim rather than trying to refute it. I was open to being shown evidence that it was true, and I tried not to imply that I was somehow set in believing otherwise.
I still had to ask like 6 times in various different threads I saw it come up in to get a single decent source. The best I got all but the last time, and not even every time, was a few pictures of a few dozen people around Nazi flags and insignia, and while it’s shit that those people are congregating and feel safe taking those pictures, I didn’t want to extrapolate from less than 50 people to an entire nation, including their leadership. I received dozens of comments insulting and belittling me, accusing me of Nazi apologia for not taking those pics as proof against the whole nation, etc. I finally got one person to share a couple articles about it, and they could best be summed up as “Ukraine has tolerated some shit they definitely shouldn’t have, perhaps for the sake of not alienating willing fighters for the war since they’re under active invasion, and that’s not okay, but .ml and Hexbear still exaggerate a lot.”
There are full books about the far-right issue in Ukraine, Ukrainian neo-nazi groups were key to escalating the violence during the unrest in 2014, commiting false-flag murders against leftist activists and police while the Western advisors and their chosen new administration for Ukraine ignored the claims. The state of Ukraine has given official honors to groups who collaborated with the Nazis in WW2. And the images you mention are part of the evidence, the fact that neo-nazi symbols are commonplace among troops is a red flag and points to the tolerance for fascism in Ukraine.
https://responsiblestatecraft.org/nazis-in-ukraine-military/
Neo-Nazi networks are deeply embedded in parts of Ukraine’s military structure. Their presence is visible in units such as Azov, the Third Assault Brigade, the Russian Volunteer Corps, Bratstvo, the German Volunteer Corps, Karpatska Sich, and others. Yet Ukraine’s Western backers continue to arm, fund, and train these units without meaningful scrutiny.
If you came away saying hexbear exaggerates a lot it is completely unsurprising you were banned, in what way are their claims exaggerated?
This is a link to a paper with a PDF download by a widely-cited researcher of the war, describing the origins of the conflict and how the far-right played a key role.
This open access book examines the Russia-Ukraine war and its origins. Based on analysis of a large number of primary and secondary sources, it provides a systematic analysis of this crucial war, its nature, outcome, possibility of peaceful settlement, violence against civilians, and origins. The book examines the role of such factors as the NATO accession of Ukraine, Russian imperialism, democracy, genocide, and the far-right in the start of the war and traces the conflict escalation ladder, which culminated in this war, to preceding violent conflicts in Ukraine, in particular, the Euromaidan, the Maidan massacre, the Russian annexation of Crimea, and the war in Donbas.
Why do you assume there is required reading
Why do you assume anyone who hasnt done “the required reading” is The Enemy
Your average bumfuck asking questions is not gonna be read up on niche eastern european social publications
I never said anyone was the enemy, my only enemy is the bourgousie, the capitalist world order, and ignorance and hatred. Posters on hexbear and .ml and other leftist online spaces try to discuss things based on the material reality of the situation, it’s important to have at least a general understanding of the real history of an event before discussing it. The link wasn’t a niche publication, the author’s points have been cited by popular newsmedia in the west many times, I’m not expecting anyone to have already read the original research but just wanted to point to an analysis of the events based on widely available evidence.
Anyone is free to ask questions without having read anything but if they get push back for sticking to long debunked imperialist talking points they shouldn’t be surprised.
Are you kidding? Why do you assume you understand a subject without ever learning about it?
There are full books about the far-right issue in Ukraine, Ukrainian neo-nazi groups were key to escalating the violence during the unrest in 2014, commiting false-flag murders against leftist activists and police while the Western advisors and their chosen new administration for Ukraine ignored the claims.
Quite possibly, I don’t know a lot about Ukraine, which is part of why I tried to approach it with an open mind. However, I would point out that for all the vitriol I received, I don’t recall anyone suggesting any books at all.
And the images you mention are part of the evidence, the fact that neo-nazi symbols are commonplace among troops is a red flag and points to the tolerance for fascism in Ukraine.
I never attempted to refute the images or what they show. I merely did not accept images of less than 50 people as proof of a systemic issue.
If you came away saying hexbear exaggerates a lot it is completely unsurprising you were banned, in what way are their claims exaggerated?
I didn’t get banned, just faced a lot of hostility for asking about it at all. Again, while trying to be open minded and inquisitive, not hurling insults or trying to call the whole thing bullshit. There was effectively no discussion of my reaction to the evidence itself. With the sole exception of the person who provided a couple articles on the topic, everyone else only commented on my request for info and my refusal to accept those few pictures as complete evidence of a systemic issue.
As for how the claims appeared exaggerated in light of what was provided to me, the articles that were eventually linked for me didn’t corroborate claims that Nazis as a faction have significant influence over the government, nor did they match the claimed extent of their prevalence. It did, however, support claims that the government had effectively looked the other way and tolerated some Nazi/fascist violence. However, since all the incidents it spoke of were from after the invasion, I find it difficult to tell if that’s because the Ukrainian government overall tacitly supports them or if they’re simply afraid to push back on a relatively militant faction that’s willing to actually help them fight back invaders. That’s not to say that it’s ever a good idea to look the other way, but I can at least understand a difference between supporting them and feeling the need to choose their battles in the moment. I still think that even under the most charitable interpretation, it’s a cursed bargain akin to trying to weaponize a rabid dog, very likely to end terribly for the one who tries to hold the leash, though.
Also you aren’t wrong about the quickness to hostility at times, part of that comes from most users on hexbear having been berated for their views essentially everywhere else they could possibly express them, it’s easy to get overly defensive.
Nah mate.
Hexbear has a reputation it has earned on its own. Its nothing to do with “poisoning against leftists” and three damned seconds in my comment history would have clued you as to where i stand politically anyway
I heard that rep, and then I made a hexbear account and primarily post from there. It’s the biggest hawk of shit that is usually only said by reactionaries that were mad they got banned for using slurs. And looking at your profile you’re right, you’d be banned for racism, as I was saying, hexbear doesn’t tolerate racism.
Oh that’s a fun one, what are you making up now?
please read the articles before commenting
No no, that would be different than the usual, we want them to fit in! Don’t tell them that!
If you find yourself thinking “hey maybe Stalin actually wasn’t that bad” you should take a break for a while
if you can’t name all six members, you can’t join the club.




