Like, Scar, my dude, you could have just taken 15 seconds to tell the hyenas your evil plan instead of wasting 4 minutes of everyone’s time singing about it.
Evita. Ruined musicals. Dragged to it as a kid. Never recovered
Yep, my powers of suspension of disbelief could not handle characters singing about stuff instead of talking
Is that my problem?! I always found musicals ridiculous and I think you’ve put your finger on it.
Imagine yourself in the scene. You’re part of a group listening to someone talk about something difficult and then they (and possibly others) break out into song and dance. Maybe even music plays out of nowhere. You’d think the person/situation is insane. I mean I watch other movies with more unrealistic things but the musicals never sat with me for the suspension of disbelief reason
I have and still do. Cannot stand them. Cannot even stand musical episodes of shows.
The only exception is Cannibal! The Musical.
Edit2: This is also why I can’t get into Bollywood.
Edit9001: Okay, there’s actually a few musicals I do like. RHPS, Rent, Chicago, Cannibal, Frozen.
Have you seen Spamalot? Never mind, don’t go, its a silly musical.
Its actually quite good if you like Monty Python.
Yes. I’m a life long hater of musicals.
Yes and you nailed the reason. A very short list of exceptions:
- Hamilton. It moves the plot along at a brisk pace and avoids the problem you said.
- the blues brothers. It is the musical format perfected. There has never been nor will there ever be another to reach that level of artistic mastery.
I don’t think of that movie as a musical, but I guess it would count technically. But it’s more diegetic than usual.
The Blues Brothers was the best musical ever made.
Hate is a strong word, but I found it hard to reconcile the fact that complete strangers knew the lyrics and dance moves to go with the protagonist’s musings.
I have always hated musicals. I will always hate musicals. They are awful.
Edit: honestly your post kinda distilled the reason why I never really liked any Disney film growing up. Thank you.
You know, I guess it depends on the musical. I grew up listening to a lot of musicals against my will just because my siblings and mom were all over that stuff, even performed a lot of it themselves at the local theatre, so I got pretty sick of hearing a lot of it. But thinking back it’s mostly the broadway musicals that I can’t stand. Cartoon musicals I’m mostly fine with, with some exceptions. I’m with you that I don’t care for the music in the lion king (which is funny because I love the music in the road to El Dorado, and both soundtracks were written by Elton John). Tarzan really didn’t need a musical number imo.
But a lot of movies I do really like the music in. Hercules songs kick ass, the Prince of Egypt goes hard, Aladdin has some good ones, and honestly most of the Disney cartoon musicals that I haven’t mentioned are at least fine.
Funny enough though, I actually like Les Mis (well except “master of the house”). It has a very different vibe than most other musicals I’ve seen, which are usually more than a bit corny and cliche.
Exact opposite. Musicals are the shit!
Every Disney cartoon up until Toy Story. Cats, Phantom of the Opera, Little Shop of Horror… I probably would have loved Rocky Horror Picture Show if I ever saw it as a kid. My favorite episode of Buffy the Vampire Slayer is “Once More With Feeling,” the musical one.
As an adult I want to know where all the musicals went.
For the most part. There’s some where its just jarring and doesnt fit the setting for me. (I was really disappointed to discover it applied to Hazbin Hotel.)

Why stop as a kid? I can’t really enjoy myself when watching a musical played out on stage, and I saw some epic spectacles. (Les Miserables, Sissy, Soldaat van Oranje). It’s just not for me.
When it’s cartoons, it’s not so bad for me. The silliness of breaking out into songs fits that world better for me. But make it a live action movie and please let me leave the theater.
I don’t know why, but I become irrationally angry when there is some musical where the actors do that fucking moronic thing where they look up wistfully and sing REAL LOUD. What are they looking at? Why are they fanning their arms out in that big slow arc? Who does that?! Why is that supposed to be entertaining?
That and the “really excited” sing that people do, big corny smile, they’re all jazzed up about going out to buy a new hat or something for no good reason. “Hey, let’s go downtown and buy a HAT!!!”. JFC. Do audiences really demand this sort of nonsense?
In live action, it always feels like a format that is more for the actors than the audience. I do sing for hobby myself and I try to be technically really good, practice over and over, and aim for a performance I would be proud of, So i have some experience with this myself (what you would do to enjoy yourself during singing, vs what would be actually fun to listen to). All those dumb moves you describe somehow just naturally come out of me while singing. Playacting out the song as a real story in my head makes me able to put more emotion in the song, and doing that will immediately summon my inner ‘musical actor/performer’ so to speak. So now it kind of looks like a guitarist bobbing along to the song to me. You don’t NEED to do that, but most musicians will enjoy doing it. I just sing Toni Braxton - Un-break my heart flatout better, if I can sometimes make my hand into a fist and dramatically and powerfully move it down.
So again, those are the exact same things that annoy me, and it just looks like what the performer themselves would most enjoy doing at that time, seemingly without caring about the actual final product (a horrible live action musical)
Nope, I loved them and still sing the songs from classic musicals like My Fair Lady and Sound of Music on a regular basis. Also a huge fan of Gilbert and Sullivan and and also most every recent Broadway music that has been nationally popular.
Noting that I do not consider cartoons, like Disnay cartoons, musicals. I only think of musicals as being live action from the start (not live action from a cartoon) or as plays.
“Hate” is too strong, but I don’t watch them. I don’t care for singing in movies as a rule, unless the movie is about a singer. Even then, I don’t want multiple full music videos embedded in the movie. Just not my thing.
We’re not alone:

Beware the changing y-axis.
this is correct, but it does say that the genres are compared by year to themselves, not to other genres.
:(
This graph shows the percentage of different movies being released… not whether those movies were popular…
What’s with the bump in the popularity of Westerns in the 60s and 70s? All I remember is that bit in Toy Story 2 where Stinky Pete complains about the launch of Sputnik.
Clint Eastwood and spaghetti western era?
I’m guessing it was harkening back to the not so distant past. Like WW2 movies and games not so long ago.
I think it might not be featuring Bollywood.
interesting graphic, thx!
Lmao at westerns entirely being a thing of the past that practically nobody cares about anymore.
I didn’t have a lot of exposure to them as a kid. I saw bits and pieces of “the sound of music”, a few Disney movies, maybe a couple more I can’t even think of at the moment, but I was more in for animated hijinx, not song numbers.
I started a weekly movie sesh with (one of) my brother(s) a few years ago, partly just to have something to do while we spent time together and consumed weed, partly to finally watch a lot of movies we had been sheltered (forbidden) from watching as kids (due to a religious upbringing, a lot of movies were verboten).
After doing this for a few years, my absolute favorite genre is now “musical”. I prefer recordings of stage plays, but I’m not too picky about that.
My current top 2 movies of any genre are now “Hairspray” and “The Book of Mormon”(which is not technically a movie, but a decent unofficial cast recording).
For me it’s all down to how much I can empathize with the characters/situation. The big group numbers (especially when characters each have a slightly different context happening within a bigger song) really get to me and just speaks right to me.
If a movie can communicate with me emotionally, it goes on the “good movie” list.
And music really does exactly that. I have no creative musical talents or skills (other than I at least used to be able to sing ok-ish, definitely not good enough to make any kind of money or career with), but music definitely makes me feel things.
I find that the musical approach to storytelling for cinema and some stage shows, including and especially book of Mormon, is a real “hit you over the head” style and because of the lack of subtlety I don’t care for it.
You should also watch Shawshank redemption if you haven’t.















